My boyfriend bought me my first piece of jewelry from him (or any guy, for that matter). I got a silver chain and pendant with diamonds and a gold accent! I'll have to get pictures of it! It was a total surprise! We've been dating for 2.5 years and I didn't have any idea that's what he was getting me. Just to make it fun and awkward, as soon as I saw it was from a jewelry store, I looked up and said, "I DO!!!"
I bought him a SodaStream soda maker! It's a blast, I can't wait until we live together and I get to play with it all the time!