Why not, I ask? If I have an outfit of 'winter white' on, I NEED to wear winter-white/off-white heels! I have a great off white sweater, and off white pants. Are "they" expecting me to wear black shoes? If I wear red, I will look like a classy hooker.I can understand if they are strappy, heeled sandals. Then I think it is the wrong season for them, but come on....Some outfits DEMAND white, off-white, light beige, etc. shoes AFTER LABOR DAY.
What do you think??? Men are also asked for their input on this issue.

They get too dirty in my line of work...and I avoid all white shoes, sandals, sneakers, etc. 

...I did a search on "white shoes after labor day" on the TLC site (what not to wear)...and received in return, a bunch of videos labeled "giving birth", "placenta", "great white sharks" etc...all from Discovery Health. Guess you can't wear white shoes while birthing your baby or swimming with sharks... 
Well, of course.